Motorists Mutual Insurance

We offer products from Motorists Mutual Insurance company to customers in Springfield and the Miami Valley area.

Learn More
File A Claim
Pay Your Bill

Motorists Mutual is owned by it’s policyholders. This allows the company to focus on doing business in a way that is best for the needs of the policyholders and for the independent agents that offer their insurance products.

Motorists Mutual has developed coverages for policyholders that have become industry standards, developed a strong working relationship with independent agents and created an environment for associates that rewards performance and innovation. It all started with smart people, looking for a better way to solve a problem. It’s a formula that still works to this day.

Personal Insurance

We offer programs from Motorists Mutual for personal insurance, including:

  • Automobile Insurance
  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Condominium Owners Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Personal Umbrella Insurance
  • Identity Theft Insurance
  • Recreational Vehicle Insurance
  • Life Insurance

Commercial Business Insurance

Commercial insurance solutions for business owners include programs for:

  • Business Owners
  • Contractors
  • Property Owners
  • Garage Owners
  • Employment Practices

File a Claim with Motorists Mutual

(800) 876-8766
File Online

Pay Your Motorists Mutual Bill

(800) 611-9928
Pay Online